Sunday, August 01, 2010

American justice?

As I have written recently, I have become somewhat disillusioned with American Justice. A good article in the Economist.( h/t) Prof  Moin Yahya talked about these kooky administrative crimes at an LSS2008. He explained that we conservatives should be careful about tough on crime. I think this is particularly true in the United States.

THREE pickup trucks pulled up outside George Norris’s home in Spring, Texas. Six armed police in flak jackets jumped out. Thinking they must have come to the wrong place, Mr Norris opened his front door, and was startled to be shoved against a wall and frisked for weapons. He was forced into a chair for four hours while officers ransacked his house. They pulled out drawers, rifled through papers, dumped things on the floor and eventually loaded 37 boxes of Mr Norris’s possessions onto their pickups. They refused to tell him what he had done wrong. “It wasn’t fun, I can tell you that,” he recalls.

Mr Norris was 65 years old at the time, and a collector of orchids. He eventually discovered that he was suspected of smuggling the flowers into America, an offence under the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species. This came as a shock. He did indeed import flowers and sell them to other orchid-lovers. And it was true that his suppliers in Latin America were sometimes sloppy about their paperwork. In a shipment of many similar-looking plants, it was rare for each permit to match each orchid precisely.

In March 2004, five months after the raid, Mr Norris was indicted, handcuffed and thrown into a cell with a suspected murderer and two suspected drug-dealers. When told why he was there, “they thought it hilarious.” One asked: “What do you do with these things? Smoke ’em?”

1 comment:

CanadianSense said...

tough on crime is for violent offences and ending 2 for 1 sentencing.

I have a problem with an arsonist, rapist, getting house arrest and the family next door having to live in fear or a hotel.

Victims need to be put ahead of the criminals and their advocates.

I Support Lord Black