Search Dr Roy's Thoughts

Thursday, May 01, 2008

Even more on Bill C-484 and the FMSQ

I am in Winnipeg for a few days for the annual meeting of Civitas. Dr Gaetan bareete of the FMSQ, returned my call today.
I expressed my great displeasure with the FMSQ position on Bill C-484. When I said he had not consulted the members he said the FMSQ is a representative organization and he did say their were doctors who did not agree with the FMSQ position , in his statements to the press. He said that most of the feedback he's had for the members mirrored his own position. The association of Ob /Gynes are the ones who brought this up. The impression of Dr Barette and the Obs is that this is a way to eventually ban abortion. I was unable to convince him otherwise.
I have offered to connect him with Mr Epp.
Gaetan also told me he got many calls from supporters of the bill who told him this was a way to criminalize abortion.

I pointed out that no other provincial medical organization has taken such a stand, Gaetan said they wre afraid. It was a very civil converstion. I thank gaetan barette for getting back to me. I will still doo all I can to change the mind of the FMSQ.
In the end we agreed to disagree. he said I was free to keep writing to the papers and expressing my opinions publicly. I will continue to do just that.

8 comments:

SUZANNE said...

It's a representative organization, but it didn't consult its members?

Was its executive consulted, at least?

Roy Eappen said...

Yes it was an executive decision. I told him the FMSQ shouldn't get involved in these political things. he replied the gynes who do abortions are afraid of prison.

SUZANNE said...

How can they be afraid of prison when the bill excludes abortion and medical acts performed in good faith?

And aren't abortions mostly done by GP's anyway? What proportion of OB\GYN's do abortions in Canada. That'd be an interesting statistic.

Another question: Did Barrette actually read the bill?

Roy Eappen said...

I told him that, but the gynes think this is a back door to recriminalizing abortion and Barette and the executive agree. It didn't help that many of our supporters called Gaetan and told him that was the case! I'm not sure who does more abortions gynes or GPs' . I will try and find out.

Joanne (True Blue) said...

It didn't help that many of our supporters called Gaetan and told him that was the case!

Why would they do that and on what basis, do you think?

Roy Eappen said...

I guess many people believe that to be the case.

Joanne (True Blue) said...

They need to be educated.

Roy Eappen said...

Agreed

View my Stats


I Support Lord Black